• kewal sethi

why satyagrah is all wrong

why satyagrah is all wrong


i came across this while reading a book 'my god is a woman' by noor zaheer (p144). this is spoken by a character.

"because satyagrah is all wrong, right form its inception. that is why the freedom we have got has taken away a chunk of our country. it worked because gandhiji understood that basically we are a lazy people, who would never be able to pick up guns and drive away the british. the least we could do was loll outside the government offices. it worked because englishman hates mess and that is what we were creating. he left because he could not stand the mess anymore."

i, personally, do not agree with all this. but in a way it explains why we are able to employ the same weapon against the misdeed of the government of the day. but it does not work any longer. the fact is that indians in command are used to the mess and creating more does not effect the present government in the same way.

i would not call ourselves merely lazy. we are also cowards. that is why a few hundred policemen can get the ram lila ground cleared in no time. look at the egyptians. how many were killed and yet the crowd only swelled. it takes guts to change the system and we have not got them. i recall jalianwala massacre. the crowd was 10000 strong. the soldiers were 50. there was only one exit. instead of running to and fro to avoid bullets, if the crowd had rushed towards the soldiers who were firing, they would have overwhelmed them. in fact if some one would have been to snatch a rufle and turned it around, the tragedy would have been over in a shorter time and definitely with lesser number of casualties.

1 view

Recent Posts

See All

न्यायाधीशों की आचार संहिता

न्यायाधीशों की आचार संहिता केवल कृष्ण सेठी (यह लेख मूलत: 7 दिसम्बर 1999 को लिखा गया था जो पुरोने कागज़ देखने पर प्राप्त हुआ। इसे ज्यों का त्यों प्रकाशित किया जा रहा है) सर्वोच्च न्यायालय तथा उच्च न्या

यक्ष प्रश्न

यक्ष प्रश्न सितम्बर 2021 ताल पर जल लाने चारों भाई यक्ष के प्रश्नों का उत्तर न देने के कारण जड़वत कर दिये गये। तब युधिष्ठर को जाना पड़ा। यक्ष के प्रश्नों का उत्तर देने को वह तैयार हो गये। होशियार तो थे ह

घर बैठे सेवा

घर बैठे सेवा कम्प्यूटर आ गया है। अब सब काम घर बैठे ही हो जायें गे। जीवन कितना सुखमय हो गा। पर वास्तविकता क्या है। एक ज़माना था मीटर खराब हो गया। जा कर बिजली दफतर में बता दिया। उसी दिन नहीं तो दूसरे दि