top of page
  • kewal sethi

the responsibility of the judiciary

the responsibility of the judiciary

in a blog sometime back, it was said that an alternative method of justice would be to involve the magistrate/judge right from the beginning in a criminal case. the intent should be to find out truth rather than weigh the evidence which the two sides want to bring up.

this view is reflected, surprisingly, in a recent judgment of Supreme Court in an appeal by maheshbhiai ranchodbhai and his parents. the court says "trial courts were expected to perform their duties of dispensing justice effectively and in line with the spirit of the authority they wield, unearth the truth when the conduct of prosecution is suspect or appears to be hand in glove with the accused."  it condemned the "parading a mock fight and making a mockery of  the criminal administration itself". there were other points like prosecution had listed 17 documents but produced only four. the husband accused of murdering his wife was given three days' imprisonment for harassment and cruelty.

but this is not enough. a swallow does not make a summer (at least in Europe). the right thing to do is to attempt to find the truth in all the cases. to that purpose, the judge should be a part of investigations right from the beginning calling for further investigation, if necessary, suggest lines in which inquiries are to proceed. he should not be there just to listen but should play an active part in the proceedings. 

to this end, we do not have to pay much attention to so called independence of judiciary. the primary duty is towards the society which is paying you for maintenance of law and order. judiciary should be part of that purpose and not aloof from it. 

it also applies to the civil cases. truth finding is, or should be, the goal not just weighing the evidence. the judge should not be a shopkeeper weighing the goods and give award to one whose pleaders and /or arguments are quantitatively more though lacking in quality. 

1 view

Recent Posts

See All

the transparency

the transparency political parties thrive on donations. like every voluntary organization, political parties too need money to manage their affairs even if it is only to pay the office staff. it is tr

the turmoil in pakistan

the turmoil in pakistan the idea of pakistan is usually associated with allama mohammad iqbal. born in sialkot in a converted hindu family, the ancestors were sapru kashmiri brahmains, he was a schol

एक पुस्तक — कुछ टिप्पणी

एक पुस्तक — कुछ टिप्पणी एकपुस्तक पढ़ी — टूहैव आर टू बी। (publisher – bloomsbury academic) । यहपुस्तक इरीच फ्रॉमने लिखी है, और इस का प्रथम प्रकाशन वर्ष 1976 में हुआ था।इसी जमाने मेंएक और पुस्तकभी आई थी


bottom of page